The central claim of electional astrology β that the sky at the moment an action begins shapes how it unfolds β cannot be tested in a way that settles it, and controlled tests of astrological prediction in general have not found evidence that it works. Many practitioners report that well-chosen times coincide with better outcomes, but such reports are anecdotal and open to selective memory.
What can be said is that choosing a deliberate moment has practical value in itself: it forces planning, creates a clear decision point, and the lunar cycle offers a convenient rhythm for starting and finishing things. No election can make up for a poor plan, difficult circumstances or lack of effort. In practice, astrologers look first at the condition of the Moon, the ruler of the Ascendant and the house of the matter in question.